Clay Aiken – Jukebox or Tried and True?

Suspicious Minds” is a song written in 1968 by Mark James (aka Francis Zambon). Performed by Elvis Presley in 1969, it became one of his most notable hits. Suspicious Minds was widely regarded as the single that jump-started Presley’s career after his successful 1968 Comeback Special. It was Presley’s last number-one single in the United States.  On their list of the 500 Greatest Songs of All Time, Rolling Stone has Suspicious Minds ranked at #91.

Elvis first performed  Suspicious Minds at the Las Vegas Hilton in July of 1969.  The single was released in the fall. It reached number one in the United States in the week of November 1st.  This song was Presley’s final number-one single in the U.S. before his death.

Clay Aiken first performed Suspicious Minds as a part of his Jukebox Tour in the summer of 2005.  On July 29th, Clay performed the song on Good Morning America’s Summer Concert Series. The performance received a great response from the audience and the chatter on all the Clay Boards was full of excitement.

Flash-forward to 2010 and Clay Aiken’s newest CD, Tried and True….  Suspicious Minds is one of the most popular songs on this album of classics.

Although the song is the same, the arrangements of both performances are somewhat different.  It is interesting to hear the differences.

There are two performances below.  The first is Clay’s performance at GMA and the second is from the taping of the Tried and True PBS special.  Which performance is your favorite?

Clay Aiken News Network is an unofficial fansite. We are not affiliated in any way with Clay Aiken or his management. This website was made by fans for fans and makes no impression or impersonation of the official site, which can be found under the domain

14 thoughts on “Clay Aiken – Jukebox or Tried and True?

  1. do you choose? I love both of them, but on the Tried & True CD, the performance and sound is soooooo polished…so I will go with that one…But I love both. There is absolutely nothing like seeing Clay in concert…. It is the best……


  2. I love the casual GMA performance and it is great, but the classy TNT one is truly excellent. Another
    Suspicious Minds performance that I really, really love is the Timeless Tour's Chautauqua one, which was video taped by Scarlett. Clay appears so relaxed and expressive in it. He is such a fantastic performer and his voice is always amazing!

  3. Very hard to I loved the JBT also. But, OMG, what a difference in his voice now. I don't know, but can it get any better or sexier? I love the look and the voice of the TNT Suspicious Minds. I think I will go watch it again.

  4. I also love both performances. It's hard to choose a favorite. I think the TNT performance is more polished, so If I had to choose, I think I'd pick the TNT performance

  5. If forced to choose, I have to say that I prefer the maturity of the 2010 version, but they are both long time faves of mine.
    Thanks for posting the two videos. I had forgotten that at the GMA performance there were 3 glimpses (from the back and sides only) of the Generation Clay contingent in their green hats, purchased just for that concert. They can be seen in the opening shots (first 30 seconds) and again at 2:45 of the video *good times!*

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.